Executive pay, share-based compensation and Directors' Dealings: the remuneration report and insider filings
Read a remuneration report critically, measure what share-based pay really costs shareholders, and interpret insider buying and selling filings.
What you will learn
- Where executive pay is disclosed in Germany and the United States and which votes shareholders have.
- How to measure share-based compensation against revenue, free cash flow and the share count.
- How to read Directors' Dealings and US Form 4 filings without over-interpreting them.
- Three pay-design questions that test whether incentives match shareholder interests.
Explanation
A German listed company publishes a Vergütungsbericht (remuneration report) under section 162 of the Aktiengesetz (AktG, the Stock Corporation Act). The annual general meeting votes on this report (section 120a AktG) and on the remuneration system at least every four years; both votes are advisory, but a rejected system must be revised for the next meeting. In the United States, pay is disclosed in the proxy statement (Form DEF 14A), including a CEO-to-median-employee pay ratio and a "pay versus performance" table, with an advisory "say-on-pay" vote.
Three design questions matter more than the headline amount. Which metrics trigger the bonus? A bonus on "adjusted EBITDA" (earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortisation, after management's own adjustments) pays management on a number it can shape. What is the time horizon? Plans vesting after three or four years align better than annual cash bonuses. Were targets changed after the fact? Look for "discretionary adjustment" or re-based targets in a bad year.
Share-based compensation (SBC) is pay in shares or options, expensed under IFRS 2 or the US standard ASC 718. It reduces reported profit but is added back in the cash flow statement because no cash leaves, so "free cash flow" and "adjusted earnings" often exclude it. For a shareholder it is a real cost paid in dilution. Measure it as a percentage of revenue, as a percentage of free cash flow, and as gross dilution (shares granted ÷ shares outstanding); then check whether buybacks only offset that dilution.
Directors' Dealings are transactions of board members, senior managers and closely associated persons in the company's own shares. Under Article 19 of the EU Market Abuse Regulation (MAR), the manager notifies the issuer and the regulator within three business days, and the issuer publishes within two business days of receipt. In Germany the duty starts once transactions reach €50,000 in a calendar year (raised by BaFin from €20,000 with effect from 1 January 2026; check the current threshold). Managers may not trade in the 30 days before an annual or half-year report (the "closed period"). In the United States, insiders file Form 4 within two business days, and since 2023 pre-arranged plans under Rule 10b5-1 require a cooling-off period, which is why filings state whether a sale was under such a plan.
Interpretation: open-market purchases with the manager's own money are informative, especially by several insiders in a short period ("cluster buying"). Sales are weaker because managers sell for taxes, houses and diversification; planned sales carry the least information, large discretionary sales shortly after optimistic statements the most.
Worked example
Hypothetical example, all figures invented, in € millions unless stated.
A software company reports revenue 2,400, operating cash flow 410, capital expenditure 130, SBC expense 96, 200 million shares outstanding, 4.0 million shares granted to employees, and buybacks of 150 at an assumed average price of €50.
- SBC ÷ revenue = 96 ÷ 2,400 = 4.0%.
- Free cash flow (FCF) = 410 − 130 = 280. FCF after SBC = 280 − 96 = 184. SBC consumes 96 ÷ 280 = 34% of the FCF the company advertises.
- Gross dilution = 4.0 ÷ 200 = 2.0% per year.
- Shares repurchased = 150 ÷ 50 = 3.0 million. Net dilution = (4.0 − 3.0) ÷ 200 = 0.5%. The "€150 million returned to shareholders" only partly offset employee grants.
Remuneration report: CEO pay €8.4 million, median employee €62,000, ratio = 8,400,000 ÷ 62,000 ≈ 135 to 1. The bonus metric, adjusted EBITDA, grew 12% while reported net income fell 5%; that gap is itself a finding.
Directors' Dealings: in the six weeks after the results, the CEO, CFO and two division heads each sold shares worth €0.4 to €2.1 million, none under a pre-arranged plan. Not proof of anything, but an open question. Taxes, fees and spreads are excluded.
Common mistake
Practice activity
Hypothetical data, € millions: revenue 900, operating cash flow 150, capital expenditure 40, SBC 54, 80 million shares outstanding, 2.4 million shares granted, buybacks 60 at an assumed €30 per share. Calculate (a) SBC as % of revenue, (b) FCF and FCF after SBC, (c) SBC as % of FCF, (d) gross dilution, (e) net dilution after buybacks; (f) how strong a signal is a CFO sale of €1.5 million under a trading plan announced four months earlier?
Show solution
(a) 54 ÷ 900 = 6.0%. (b) FCF = 150 − 40 = 110; FCF after SBC = 110 − 54 = 56. (c) 54 ÷ 110 = 49%: nearly half the advertised FCF is paid away in shares. (d) 2.4 ÷ 80 = 3.0%. (e) Shares repurchased = 60 ÷ 30 = 2.0 million; net dilution = (2.4 − 2.0) ÷ 80 = 0.5%. (f) Weak: a sale under a plan set up months earlier was decided before current results were known.
Limitations: this ignores option exercise prices and vesting conditions, which change the real cost; the SBC note gives the detail.
Key takeaways
- Read the remuneration report for metrics, horizon and after-the-fact changes, not only for the headline amount.
- SBC is a real cost: compute FCF after SBC, SBC as a share of FCF, and net dilution after buybacks.
- Directors' Dealings: cluster purchases are strong signals; planned sales are weak; discretionary sales after optimistic statements deserve a question.
- Thresholds change: as of 2026 the German notification threshold is €50,000 per calendar year; check the current rule.
Next step
Next, you will read earnings-call transcripts and learn to recognise non-answers, guidance language and what the analysts' questions reveal.
Self-check
Answer the questions, then check your answers. You can retry as often as you like.
Automatic self-check for your own revision. Your answers are checked in your browser and are not seen or assessed by us. It is not an exam and not a qualification.
Your progress
“Complete” only means you marked the lesson as done. It is not a test of your understanding. Progress and notes are saved only in this browser on this device — not in an account.